Matter was supposed to fix the smart home—but stuff is now more confusing than ever. Is there light at the end of the tunnel?
eufy’s 3-in-1 E20 is MSRP $549.99, but with $100 off, you can get this beast for $449.99:
Also available on Amazon:
Follow Snazzy Labs on Twitter –
Follow me on Bluesky –
Follow me on Threads –
Follow me on Mastodon –
Follow me on Instagram –
In this video, we dive into why smart homes still fail to deliver on their promise, despite advancements like Matter. From unreliable automations to poorly integrated smart home devices, the video exposes how even popular platforms like Google Home and Amazon Alexa fall short. We break down how local control and unified apps like Home Assistant could fix the broken smart home experience while highlighting why so many IoT devices continue to frustrate users.
0:00 Quinn’s smart home rules reign supreme
0:56 Matter explained, simply
2:02 Matter != Thread
3:35 Matter explained, not simply…
4:26 Matter isn’t an ecosystem—and that’s a problem
6:28 Matter adoption is… spotty
7:50 Matter may fail on its ONE promise
9:13 Matter won’t eliminate apps
9:55 Matter devices don’t just appear cross-platform
10:41 Matter “Multi-Admin” is terrible
12:39 I’ve moved from HomeKit to Home Assistant
14:50 Matter is a net good—but it’s not “good”
Do you think eufy’s E20 is a smart design or just a gimmick?
Matter still matters; it just isn’t going to solve the ecosystem problem because people only want one ecosystem to begin with. Matter matters because it provides an incentive for developers to open their APIs enough to make their products function with ecosystems like Google, Apple, or Home Assistant. If consumers are more likely to buy Matter devices, manufacturers will be incentivized to offer support for an open platform (looking at you Schluter and your Ditra-heat system).
Tuya does not make your home bullet proof. It goes down and it’s not locally controllable. Which violates your rules of being locally controlled. Even with HA, it talks to tuya servers. You need matter for local control…period
You have great videos! But… You are NOT correct about IPv6 needing to be enabled. That is hands down the worst advice that could be given. That opens a whole world of battles with some legacy devices on the network.
Matter devices communicate directly with their own mesh Network to each other using IPv6. They could care less about which protocol is used on your wifi network.
Whatever hub you are using will translate it back to the wifi network using IPv4. Which is actually more stable due to the risk of incompatibility with some legacy devices that might be on your network.
Anywho… I highly recommend that you correct that.
I could be wrong here, but wasn’t Google a major player in developing the matter standard?!? Wdym they are struggling to support the current versions of it. 💀